Analysis 12 min read

Angi vs HomeAdvisor vs Thumbtack: It's Really Two Companies, and They Bill Pros Very Differently

HomeAdvisor and Angi belong to the same Nasdaq-listed company. Thumbtack is a separate, private rival. Here is how each one works for homeowners, what pros actually sign up for, how bad leads get handled, and why both are now racing to answer your questions inside ChatGPT and Google.

Close-up of a roofer's hands tightening a fastener on a pale metal roof with a socket wrench, one work boot planted beside the panel and trees blurred in the background.

“Angi vs HomeAdvisor” is a heavily searched comparison in home services, and it rests on a small misunderstanding. They aren’t competitors. Angi Inc., the Nasdaq-listed company that trades as ANGI, says in its latest quarterly filing that it “operates under multiple brands including Angi, Angie’s List, HomeAdvisor, and Handy.” The real comparison is Angi’s family of brands against Thumbtack, a privately held marketplace based in San Francisco.

That still leaves a real choice, for homeowners and especially for the plumbers, roofers, cleaners and remodelers who pay to be listed. The two companies make money from the same basic transaction, a homeowner looking for help. But they meter it differently, they handle bad leads differently, and over the past year both have moved to meet homeowners inside AI assistants rather than waiting for them to show up on a search results page.

The short version

  • If you’re a homeowner, Angi and Thumbtack are both free to use. Angi says you can compare pros, book services and request quotes “all for free”, and Thumbtack calls its homeowner app “one free app”. The pros pay. The practical difference for you is how each one narrows the field and how much it now leans on AI to do it.
  • If you’re a pro, you are choosing between two billing models. Angi works from a monthly lead budget, and its own help pages refer to annual subscriptions. Thumbtack has you set an exact price per lead for each service and a weekly budget, and says there is “no charge to join, no annual fees and no membership fees.”
  • If a lead goes nowhere, the rules differ sharply. Thumbtack automatically refunds a lead when the customer doesn’t reply to any pro within 72 hours. Angi treats an unresponsive homeowner as part of the price of a lead and doesn’t credit it.

At a glance

Angi (incl. HomeAdvisor)Thumbtack
Who owns itAngi Inc., listed on Nasdaq (ANGI) since its spin-off from IAC on 31 March 2025Thumbtack, Inc., privately held
Cost to homeownersFree to search, book and request quotes, with an optional paid membershipFree app
How pros payLeads billed against a monthly budget; annual subscriptions also offeredAn exact price per lead that the pro sets, drawn from a weekly budget
Membership or joining feeAnnual subscriptions are offered, per Angi’s billing FAQ”No charge to join, no annual fees and no membership fees”
What sets the lead price”Task, homeowner location, and demand for the work”The price the pro sets for each service
How a lead is createdSince January 2025, the homeowner picks the proThe customer contacts pros from search results, capped at five in the first four hours
Lead the customer never answersNot eligible for a creditRefunded automatically after 72 hours with no reply to any pro
Leads you go after yourself”Opportunities,” charged when the homeowner shows interest back, or immediately if you accept”Opportunities,” priced upfront and charged only if the customer responds
AI assistantsApps in ChatGPT (March 2026) and Gemini (August 2026); in Google’s AI Mode (November 2026)ChatGPT app announced October 2025; AI-guided search in testing

The sections below source every row.

One company, several front doors

Angi Inc. was formed in 2017 when IAC combined HomeAdvisor, which began in 1998 as ServiceMagic, with Angie’s List. Angie’s List now goes by Angi, and Angi says the business was founded in 1995. HomeAdvisor never went away as a consumer site. Homeadvisor.com still invites homeowners to “find top-rated pros in your area” and lists pre-priced offerings such as home cleaning and roof repair.

The scale is in Angi’s filings. For the quarter ended 30 September 2026, the company reported about 101,000 average monthly active pros in the US and said consumers had used its businesses to find a pro for about 15 million projects over the trailing twelve months. Quarterly revenue was $242.0 million, against $265.6 million a year earlier.

Thumbtack describes itself as a community of 300,000 local service businesses, and its pro page advertises “over 30,000+ leads on Thumbtack per day.” Those figures don’t line up with Angi’s, because the two companies count different things: active pros in a quarter on one side, a network of businesses and a daily lead count on the other. Treat them as a sense of size, not a ranking.

How it works if you’re hiring

Both marketplaces start the same way. You describe the job, and the platform shows you pros. What happens next has converged.

At Angi, the big change came in January 2025 with what the company calls “homeowner choice.” On its first-quarter call that year, Angi told investors that “every lead sent to a professional on Angi is because a homeowner specifically chose that professional through our interface,” and that a year earlier around 40% of its leads had been matched automatically. In practice, a homeowner no longer submits a request and gets called by whichever pros the system assigns. They pick.

Thumbtack’s help center describes a similar flow. Customers describe the project “in their own words (or by sharing a photo in the app),” are shown the pros who fit best “and why each one is a good match,” and then reach out to the ones they like.

Angi also sells work directly. Its FAQ lists “Angi Services, where projects are booked and completed by Angi” as one of its three revenue sources, alongside pro advertising and paid homeowner memberships. The pre-priced offerings with “from” prices on HomeAdvisor’s homepage appear to be the same idea. If you’d rather book a set-price job than collect quotes, Angi offers that route.

How it works if you’re paying

This is where the two really part ways.

Angi. A pro sets a monthly budget, which Angi’s billing FAQ defines as “the target dollar value of leads that Angi will match you with each month.” The budget is a target, not a cap. The FAQ’s own example is a pro with a $500 budget who has used $480 and still receives a $40 lead, ending the month at $520. Pros on an annual subscription are billed on the same day each month. Everyone else is billed weekly. Angi says lead pricing “varies based on task, homeowner location, and demand for the work.”

Thumbtack. A pro sets a price for every service they offer, and Thumbtack’s help center says that “the price you set for a lead is the exact amount you’ll pay,” unless a discount or promotion applies. According to Thumbtack, setting a higher price for a service makes you more competitive for those leads. The leads come out of a weekly budget that resets on Monday. If the lead that uses up your budget costs more than you have left, you pay the full price, but the overage is capped at “up to 40% of your budget amount or $40 plus 2% of your budget, whichever is less.”

Both companies also offer leads that the pro chases instead of receiving, and both call them Opportunities. On Thumbtack these are customers who have contacted other pros but haven’t hired anyone yet. The price is shown upfront and is charged only if you reach out and the customer responds. On Angi, showing interest in an Opportunity triggers a charge once the homeowner shows interest back, and accepting one charges you immediately. Either way, the cost sits on top of your monthly budget.

Angi’s help pages explain what drives lead prices rather than listing them, and on Thumbtack you set the price yourself. Either way, the real cost per lead in your trade and ZIP code only becomes clear inside the account.

When a lead goes nowhere

For a pro, this is the most important row in the table. It is also the one most comparisons skip.

Thumbtack’s Quality Commitment promises two things. It caps competition, limiting a customer to contacting five pros in the first four hours of their search. And it offers what it calls Fair Shot Refunds: “if a customer doesn’t reply to any pro they contacted within the first 72 hours, we’ll automatically give you a refund for the lead.”

Angi’s credit policy covers a different set of failures. It may credit a lead after investigation for invalid contact details, a job outside your ZIP codes, a service you don’t offer, a duplicate within 45 days, or a lead charged while your account was paused. To qualify, you must request it within 45 days, have tried calling the homeowner within 24 hours, and not be on an annual subscription. Angi states plainly that a homeowner who never answers, hires someone else first, or is just “in the ‘shopping phase’” is “accounted for in our lead pricing” and not eligible. Credits expire after six months.

Neither approach is wrong. They are different bets. Thumbtack carries more of the risk of a customer who goes quiet. Angi says it prices that risk into every lead instead. Our read is that a pro who gets a lot of tire-kickers will feel the difference most.

The regulatory backstory

HomeAdvisor’s lead sales have a regulatory history worth knowing. In April 2023 the Federal Trade Commission approved a final order against HomeAdvisor, Inc. It required the company to pay up to $7.2 million in redress and barred it from making false or misleading claims about its leads. The FTC had alleged that HomeAdvisor made “false, misleading, or unsubstantiated claims about the quality and source of the leads” it sold to service providers.

The business model changed again less than two years later. When Angi removed automatic matching in January 2025, leads from what it calls its network channel collapsed. These were service requests from consumers shown Angi pros through third-party websites. Its fourth-quarter 2025 results show network leads down 78% in that quarter, which the company put down to the switch. On its first-quarter 2025 investor call, Angi said its pro win rate, meaning how often a pro wins a job from a lead they paid for, rose 10% afterwards.

The new front door is a chat window

The most consequential difference between these marketplaces in 2027 may not be their pricing. It may be how well each one shows up when a homeowner asks an AI assistant what to do about a leaking water heater.

Angi has stacked up launches:

  • June 2025: it launched AI Helper, which it says lets homeowners describe issues in their own words and turns them into the kind of service request pros prefer.
  • March 2026: it launched an Angi app in ChatGPT. A homeowner can go from a question in ChatGPT to pro recommendations, then on to Angi to continue in AI Helper. Angi says AI Helper users are “3× more likely to request a quote from a skilled pro than traditional browsing users.”
  • August 2026: it became a connected app in Gemini, available from 13 August.
  • November 2026: it appeared in AI Mode in Google Search, where choosing an Angi pro takes the homeowner to that pro’s Angi profile.

Thumbtack has moved on two fronts. In October 2025 it announced that it was building an app for ChatGPT, using OpenAI’s Apps SDK, to let US users “ask home questions and discover, connect with, and hire skilled professionals” without leaving the chat. In April 2026 it introduced an AI-powered experience that “replaces search with a guided approach.” Homeowners describe a problem by text, photo or voice, the AI scopes the project, and Thumbtack returns a curated list of local pros with an explanation of why each fits. The company said 87% of customers in early testing found it valuable to describe their issue through photos or voice, and that it planned to bring the experience to all users in 2026.

Our analysis: for pros, this shifts where the competition happens. When an assistant shortlists two or three pros and explains why, your profile, reviews, photos and stated services are doing the selling before a homeowner ever reaches a list. The marketplace still sends the bill. The assistant increasingly decides who is in the running. Pros already deciding whether to pay for leads should also look at the AI tools that answer and book the calls those leads produce. We cover two of them in Housecall Pro vs Jobber, where both now sell AI call answering.

Which one should you use?

Homeowners: use whichever surfaces good pros for your job. With both free, there is no reason not to check both Angi and Thumbtack on a big project. If you want a fixed price instead of a quote, Angi’s pre-priced services are worth a look. Whichever you use, check licensing and insurance yourself before you hire.

Pros: the choice is really about how you want to carry risk.

  • Thumbtack suits a pro who wants a predictable, self-set price on every lead, no membership or joining fee, and an automatic refund when a customer goes silent. In return, you manage lead prices service by service.
  • Angi suits a pro who wants volume from the longer-established network and is comfortable with a monthly budget and possibly an annual subscription. The trade-off is fewer grounds for credits, and none at all on a subscription.
  • Before signing with either, ask for the current lead price in your trade and service area in writing. Ask what happens to your spend when a homeowner never responds. If you’re offered an annual subscription, ask how cancellation works.

Our take

The search term is a relic. “Angi vs HomeAdvisor” asks a question that was settled when the two merged in 2017. The live question is Angi against Thumbtack, and it is less about which has more pros than about who carries the cost of a lead that goes nowhere.

Thumbtack has made that cost its selling point: exact prices, a competition limit and automatic refunds. Angi has spent nearly two years rebuilding around homeowner choice and is now putting itself everywhere a homeowner might ask an AI for help.

If I were a small contractor deciding where to spend my next $500, I’d start on Thumbtack. Its terms are the easiest to understand before you’ve spent anything. I would also keep a close eye on Angi’s AI distribution. Being the pro an assistant recommends may soon matter more than which marketplace you pay.